Nikola’s Milton Seeks Dismissal of Case He Misled Investors (1)

Nikola Corp. founder Trevor Milton asked a federal judge to throw out an indictment accusing him of misleading investors about the electric vehicle maker’s financial prospects.

Milton filed multiple motions to dismiss charges on Wednesday, saying he wasn’t given fair notice that the alleged statements he made could be considered criminal and that prosecutors haven’t shown how his comments influenced purchases or sales of Nikola stock, among other arguments.

“The government’s theory of criminal liability is novel and breathtaking in scope, threatening core rights protected by the Constitution,” according to the filings.

Instead of focusing on alleged misstatements in offering documents or financial statements as usual in securities fraud cases, Milton argues, the government calls out his “tweets, social media posts, podcasts, and television or print interviews -- many of which were made or conducted long before Nikola was a public company -- in an attempt to criminalize promotional speech about Nikola’s products.”

Milton pleaded not guilty in July and was freed on $100 million bail, among the stiffest terms exacted recently, along with Tom Barrack’s $250 million bond. A federal judge last month rejected Milton’s bid to throw out the case for lack of proper jurisdiction or to transfer it to Utah, where he lives, or Arizona, where Nikola is based. He has appealed the ruling.

Read More: Nikola Founder Milton Faces Charges He Lied to Support Stock

The charges against Milton followed a tough year for the company, which faced questions about its production and technology almost immediately after going public. Milton, the former chairman, stepped down from Nikola last year.

Nikola last month disclosed talks with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission over a potential settlement in which the company would pay a civil penalty of $125 million, and come a step closer to clearing the shadow cast by Milton’s alleged acts. Nikola said it would seek reimbursement from Milton for legal costs associated with government probes.

Since being indicted, Milton has sold more than $300 million of Nikola stock. While it isn’t clear if he’s liquidating the shares to fund his legal defense, his selling has been tracked closely by investors. Representatives for Milton haven’t responded to requests for comment on the share sales.

Milton remains Nikola’s single largest shareholder, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. He also holds stock through an entity, T&M Residual, owned jointly with the company’s current chief executive officer, Mark Russell. Nikola has said Russell manages the T&M shares independently of Nikola.

The case is U.S. v. Trevor Milton, 21-cr-00478, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan).

Read More: Nikola Jumps After Revealing Possible Pact With SEC

(Adds details and context starting in second paragraph.)

To contact the reporters on this story:
Chris Dolmetsch in Federal Court in Manhattan at cdolmetsch@bloomberg.net;
Ed Ludlow in San Francisco at eludlow2@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Katia Porzecanski at kporzecansk1@bloomberg.net

Peter Jeffrey

© 2021 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. Used with permission.