Bloomberg Law
Free Newsletter Sign Up
Bloomberg Law
Free Newsletter Sign Up

Moderna Drops After Losing Appeal Over Drug-Delivery Patents (2)

Dec. 1, 2021, 10:25 PM

Moderna Inc. shares plunged after the pharmaceutical company lost an appeal of a patent ruling involving a rival’s drug-delivery technology, which couldmake its Covid-19 vaccine vulnerable to infringement suits.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit on Wednesday affirmed decisions by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board on two Arbutus Biopharma Corp. patents. The court said Moderna had no standing to appeal the ruling on one patent because it hadn’t developed its Covid vaccine until after it filed the appeal -- the pandemic hadn’t yet begun. The panel also affirmed the board’s finding that Moderna hadn’t proven the second patent covers an obvious invention.

Moderna was the S&P 500 Index’s worst performer, dropping 12% in New York trading. Arbutus jumped 44%, while its largest shareholder, Roivant Sciences Ltd., rose 34%, its biggest one-day gain since the biotech company’s reverse merger last year.

“Ultimately, we think the parties will go to court but will settle for a small royalty in due course,” Dennis Ding, an analyst with Jefferies, said in a research note.

Genevant Sciences Inc., launched jointly in 2018 by Arbutus and Roivant, has licenses to the patents. Roivant has an 80% stake in Genevant.

Moderna’s future is tied to the Covid vaccine. The company reported $60.2 million in revenue in 2019, a figure that jumped to $803.4 million last year, boosted by federal grants. The Cambridge, Massachusetts-based company has projected about $20 billion in sales this year, almost all of it from the Covid vaccine.

A Moderna spokeswoman said the court’s patent ruling is unrelated to the company’s dispute with the U.S. National Institutes of Health over whether government scientists should have been included as co-inventors of Moderna’s Covid-19 vaccine in a key patent application.

A representative of Arbutus didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Warminster, Pennsylvania-based Arbutus was “heavily favored” to win the appeals, which could lead to an infringement suit against Moderna, Jefferies analysts Kelechi Chikere and Michael Yee had said in a note to clients.

Lipid Nanoparticles

The patents cover lipid nanoparticles -- tiny balls of fat that protect genetic material as it travels through the body to enter specific cells to deliver drugs. Messenger RNA, the genetic material at the heart of the Covid vaccines, needs the lipid nanoparticles as a protective shell.

Royalties from nerve-function drug Onpattro -- the first Food and Drug Administration-approved medicine that used Arbutus’s technology -- form the only source of revenue for Arbutus, which reported just $6.9 million in licensing fees last year.

Investors have been speculating that the Arbutus patents, directed to a more stable lipid nanoparticle, will entitle the company to royalties from the mRNA-based vaccines by Moderna and Pfizer Inc. Moderna has a license to the Arbutus patents, but it’s limited to the areas of a respiratory virus known as RSV, Influenza A, and the mosquito-transmitted viruses Chikungunya and Zika.

Moderna preemptively challenged three Arbutus patents on the technology at the PTAB, with mixed results. The board invalidated one patent not at issue in the Federal Circuit’s latest two rulings, upheld all of another, and upheld some claims of a third.

Moderna appealed, challenging the board’s findings that it didn’t show parts of the patents were obvious and anticipated.

The cases are Arbutus Biopharma Corp. v. Moderna Therapeutics Inc., 20-1186; and Moderna TX Inc. v. Arbutus Biopharma Corp., 20-2329, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.

(Updates share prices, analyst comments and details about Genevant Sciences’ licenses.)

--With assistance from Susan Decker, Robert Langreth and Cristin Flanagan.

To contact the reporters on this story:
Christopher Yasiejko in Wilmington, Delaware, at;
Perry Cooper in Arlington at;
Matthew Bultman in Arlington at

To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Katia Porzecanski at

Steve Stroth

© 2021 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. Used with permission.