Bloomberg Law
May 12, 2020, 5:32 PM

Fauci Warns Early Reopening Could ‘Set You Back,’ Cause Deaths

Laura Litvan
Laura Litvan
Bloomberg News

Anthony Fauci, the nation’s top infectious disease official, warned against reopening the economy too soon, telling a Senate panel Thursday that communities doing so risk new coronavirus outbreaks.

Fauci told the Senate Health Committee Tuesday that he’s concerned about cities and states reopening without reaching “checkpoints” outlined by the administration in guidelines to help them decide when it’s safe.

Anthony Fauci speaks via teleconference during a Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee hearing in Washington, D.C. on May 12.
Photographer: Win McNamee/Getty Images/Bloomberg

“I feel if that occurs, there is a real risk that you will trigger an outbreak that you might not be able to control,” Fauci said. “In fact, paradoxically it will set you back -- not only leading to some suffering and death that could be avoided but it could even set you back on the road on trying to get economic recovery. That would turn the clock back rather than going forward.”

Fauci’s call for caution puts him in conflict with President Donald Trump‘s race to reopen the country for business and ease restrictions that have crushed the economy.

The checkpoints that Fauci cited call for a succession of steps toward gradual reopening, including a “downward trajectory” of documented cases or positive coronavirus tests “within a 14-day period.”

The panel’s Republican chairman, Senator Lamar Alexander, opened the hearing -- with lawmakers and witnesses appearing largely by video from their homes or offices for the 3 1/2 hours of questioning -- by reaffirming his view that the administration’s efforts to increase testing capacity are “impressive but not nearly enough.”

“Before we spend too much time finger-pointing, I would like to suggest that almost all of us -— the United States and almost every country as far I could tell —- underestimated this virus,” he said. “Underestimated how contagious it would be. How it can travel silently without causing symptoms. How it can be especially deadly for certain segments of our population.”

But Senator Patty Murray, the panel’s ranking Democrat, said “the Trump administration’s response to this public health emergency so far has been a disaster all on its own.”

‘Delays, Missteps’

“Delays, missteps have put us way behind where we need to be on diagnostic tests and allowed inaccurate antibody tests to come to market,” said Murray, whose home state of Washington was the first in the U.S. to be hit with a wave of coronavirus cases. “Corruption and political interference have impeded efforts to secure desperately needed personal protective equipment and promoted dangerous, unproven treatments.”

Amid the sharpest downturn in U.S. history, Trump has been pressing to begin relaxing the lockdowns that have shuttered businesses despite warnings from some public health experts that doing so too quickly risks a further spread of the virus.

Donald Trump speaks during a press briefing on Monday, May 11.
Photographer: Oliver Contreras/Sipa/Bloomberg

“I want it to reopen safely, but I want it to reopen,” Trump said at a White House news conference Monday, where he and other administration officials insisted there’s enough testing available to support initial efforts to reopen the country.

The circumstances of the Health Committee hearing, which include Fauci as well as Robert Redfield, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, accentuated the difficulty the U.S. faces as states move to let businesses reopen and encourage consumers to go out and spend.

Plans for the hearing took an abrupt twist on Sunday when Fauci, Redfield and a third witness -- Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Stephen Hahn -- all said they had come into contact with a member of the White House staff who tested positive for the coronavirus and were in full or partial quarantine.

Read More: Trump Says ‘We Have Prevailed’ in Testing as Deaths Top 80,000

Lamar Alexander
Photographer: Andrew Harnik/AP Photo/Bloomberg

Alexander, the chairman, led the hearing from his home in Tennessee, as he’s also in self quarantine “out of an abundance of caution” after one of his aides tested positive for COVID-19 on Sunday, according to a statement from his office.

A fourth witness, Assistant Health and Human Services Secretary Brett Giroir, also testified by video.

Under questioning by Republican Senator Kelly Loeffler of Georgia, all of the witnesses denied what she portrayed as inaccurate media reports that they had strained dealings with Trump. “There is certainly not a confrontational relationship between me and the president,” Fauci said.

Giroir testified that states and territories aim to do 12.9 million tests over the next four weeks. That compares with about 9.4 million tests that the U.S. has done to date.

‘Likely Higher’

Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, who sought the Democratic presidential nomination this year, said Trump “downplayed” the risks of the pandemic and has retaliated against officials who spoke out.

Bernie Sanders speaks via teleconference during a Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee hearing on May 12.
Photographer: Win McNamee/Getty Images/Bloomberg

Asked by Sanders if Fauci agrees with official estimates that about 80,000 Americans have died, he said “most of us feel the number of deaths is likely higher,” adding “almost certainly it’s higher.”

Fauci also said a renewed outbreak in the fall is possible “even if we get better control” over the pandemic.

But Republican Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky, who tested positive for coronavirus earlier in the pandemic, said that “if we keep kids out of school for another season” poor children will go another year without learning.

“I think we better be careful” not to be “cavalier in thinking that children are completely immune to the deterious effects” of the virus, Fauci responded.


In one of the sharper exchanges in the hearing, Paul said Fauci shouldn’t be thought of as “the end-all” on the coronavirus issue and called for a faster reopening of the economy. Paul said the virus had been “relatively benign” in much of the country.

“The history of this when we look back will be wrong prediction after wrong prediction,” Paul said.

Fauci, who asked to be allowed to respond, said his advice was based on “the best scientific evidence” available.

“I have never made myself out to be the end all and only voice in this,” Fauci said.

The government scientist also said the U.S. should be careful because much was still being learned about the virus - including the “strange inflammatory syndrome” observed in some children.

Read More: All the Covid-19 Symptoms You Didn’t Know About

Trump had blocked Fauci from testifying to a House panel on the coronavirus, saying that chamber is controlled by Democrats and “they put every Trump hater on the committee.”

Senator Chris Murphy, a Connecticut Democrat, said guidelines provided by the administration were “criminally vague” and pressed Redfield for the release of more specific guidance that was developed by his agency but subsequently shelved by the White House.

“States are reopening right now, and we need this additional guidance to make those decisions,” Murphy said. Redfield said the information will be posted “soon” on the CDC’s website.

The White House has had its own brush with the spread of the virus in unexpected places. Trump said Monday he demanded that everyone entering the West Wing wear a face mask after a White House valet and Vice President Mike Pence’s press secretary tested positive for coronavirus infection.

(Updates in 16th paragraph with officials commenting on relationship with Trump)

--With assistance from Anna Edney and Emma Court.

To contact the reporters on this story:
Laura Litvan in Washington at;
Justin Sink in Washington at

To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Joe Sobczyk at

Larry Liebert, Magan Crane

© 2020 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. Used with permission.