Bloomberg Law
Free Newsletter Sign Up
Bloomberg Law
Free Newsletter Sign Up

Omicron Surge Gives Bosses Reason to Order Shots Biden Can’t (1)

Jan. 14, 2022, 2:18 PM

The U.S. Supreme Court may have rejected a federal rule mandating Covid-19 vaccinations or testing, but businesses threatened by omicron’s spread might be forced to implement one anyway to protect the workers they have and keep factories open.

While many companies have already imposed their own vaccine requirements, about 1 in 3 employers planned to do so only if the Occupational Safety and Health Administration rule took effect. Those companies now face a decision, one that might be forced upon them by surging Covid-19 infection rates that have sent absenteeism soaring at plants, hospitals and other workplaces.

WATCH: A divided U.S. Supreme Court blocked an Occupational Safety and Health Administration rule that would have required 80 million workers to get shots or periodic tests. David Westin explains.
Source: Bloomberg

“With this new variant, employers who were on the fence before about doing a mandate will have to look at whether testing or vaccination will be necessary just to continue operating,” said Rachel Conn, an employment and OSHA partner at law firm Nixon Peabody LLP. “It may be about just keeping the facility open at this point.”

Omicron’s surge has once again delayed companies’ plans to get workers back at their desks and prompted asset-management giant Blackstone Inc. to require booster shots to work in its office. More than two dozen industry groups opposed the federal government forcing their hand on Covid-19 policies, but individual companies aren’t necessarily against mandates, especially if they keep business running.

“As a practical matter, employers are looking at how to lower their risk,” said Jeff Levin-Scherz, the population health leader at workplace consultant Willis Towers Watson. “Getting people vaccinated is an important way to prevent Covid from interrupting their business.”

Absent Workers

Almost 1.8 million workers were absent in November because of illness, according to the most recent figures from the Labor Department, and that was before the omicron variant hit the U.S. Only 63% of the country is fully vaccinated, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Businesses that were already grappling with inflation, supply-chain snafus and workers quitting in record numbers now have to deal with the rampaging variant as well.

The OSHA rule, pushed by President Joe Biden, would have applied to all businesses with 100 or more employees, requiring about 80 million workers to get Covid-19 vaccines or periodic tests.

Read more: Court blocks Biden mandate for contractors

The situation is further complicated by a separate mandate for federal contractors, which would affect many of the nation’s largest private-sector employers, from defense firm Raytheon Technologies Corp. to tech giant Microsoft Corp. That requirement, originally slated to go into effect Jan. 4, remains in limbo after a district court judge halted it last month.

The National Retail Federation called the Supreme Court’s decision “a significant victory for employers,” mirroring comments that trickled out Thursday afternoon from other industry groups opposed to the rule, such as the American Trucking Association. Businesses were also worried about how the directive would be implemented and enforced, while many employees feared they would have to shoulder the costs of regular testing.

What Bloomberg Intelligence Says:

OSHA estimated the cost to all industries for compliance -- including for vaccine administration, paid time off, reporting and other costs -- was $3 billion. Challengers claimed it would be far more. Sectors that could have had the highest compliance costs included educational services, and animal and crop production.

-- Holly Froum, BI litigation analyst

Click here to read the research.

“The big question now is, What are employers going to do moving forward?” Conn said. “A lot of them were on the fence and now will have to make a decision.”

Ford Motor Co. is one of the companies that now has decisions to make. The automaker is reviewing the ruling to see if any changes are needed to its vaccine mandate for most of its 32,000 salaried U.S. workers. It hasn’t required vaccinations for its 57,000 hourly U.S. workers, who are represented by the United Auto Workers union, which opposes mandates.

“Ford continues to strongly encourage all employees who are eligible to get vaccinated, and we are encouraged by the 88% of U.S. salaried employees who are already vaccinated,” the company said in an emailed statement.

‘OSHA Light’

Businesses that see the need to implement some sort of shot-or-test policy might pursue what employment lawyers are calling an “OSHA light” approach, where employees are allowed to self-report their Covid test results rather than requiring administrative vetting and oversight by an outside party. That might appease some workers, while others might worry that essentially relying on the honor system isn’t enough to keep everyone safe.

“Private sector employers still have the right to roll out and maintain a vaccine mandate policy or a vax-or-test-policy,” said Ian Carleton Schaefer, chair of law firm Loeb & Loeb’s New York employment and labor practice. “The decision point is now squarely left to board rooms and chief executives to decide.”

Executives seeking guidance on the conundrum could look to United Airlines Holdings Inc. Chief Executive Officer Scott Kirby.

Earlier this week, the airline chief said about 3,000 of its workers had tested positive for Covid-19, but United’s mandatory vaccination policy had kept the infected out of hospitals.

The carrier’s sick workers are part of the more than 11 million Americans who aren’t working because of the virus, according to the Census Bureau’s latest Household Pulse Survey. (That figure also includes those who refrain from working because they are worried about getting or spreading the virus, and those caring for someone with symptoms.)

As companies weigh their decision, more and more workers will likely fall victim to the virus. Epidemiologist David Michaels, who led OSHA under President Barack Obama and now teaches at George Washington University, said employers who choose not to enforce any sort of vaccine or testing mandate put the economy at risk.

“Many, many workers will continue to be infected, and millions of workers will remain outside the workforce because they are afraid of becoming infected,” he said. “Until we make workplaces safe we won’t be able to bring the economy back to normal or address the very significant supply chain issues that we face right now.”

(Updates with Bloomberg Intelligence analysis)

--With assistance from Jordyn Holman, Josh Eidelson, Catherine Larkin and Keith Naughton.

To contact the reporter on this story:
Matthew Boyle in New York at

To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Brian Bremner at

Crayton Harrison, Rob Golum

© 2022 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. Used with permission.