Initial calls for racial audits at Wall Street banks and other corporations were rejected by shareholders, but support was high enough that companies are likely to face increased pressure to agree to future reviews.
Shareholder proposals for independent racial audits filed at Johnson & Johnson and Citigroup Inc.received backing from more than a third of shareholders at annual meetings this month. At Goldman Sachs Group Inc., 29% of shareholders voted for an audit at the company’s annual meeting Thursday. The investors’ recommendations called for a deep-dive analysis into the companies’ business models -- from policies to products and services -- to determine whether they cause or perpetuate racial inequities.
While the proposals failed to pass, enough shareholders voted for them to send “a warning shot that the companies should take notice,” said Rob Du Boff, an environmental, social and governance analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence. The next step would be for proponents to withhold support for directors that oversee the issue, such as those on the corporate responsibility or risk committees, he said.
The racial audits are part of a broader push by shareholders to hold companies accountable for statements of support they made to minority communities last year after the killing of George Floyd by police prompted widespread protests. Shareholders also want companies to provide more transparency about the diversity of their employees and show how their political contributions line up with their social positions.
New York State Common Retirement Fund, CtW Investment Group and Service Employees International Union were the investors that filed proposals calling for racial audits. BlackRock Inc., the world’s largest asset-management firm, broke ranks with its financial-services peers earlier this month by agreeing to perform one, joining companies including Airbnb Inc. and Facebook Inc. that have conducted audits in recent years.
Color of Change, the influential racial justice group, is also calling on Alphabet Inc.’s Google to allow an independent racial audit following the ouster of two women who led the company’s Ethical AI team.
Overall shareholder support for activists’ social proposals is rising. About 29% of shareholders voted in favor of social proposals opposed by companies so far this proxy season. That’s the highest in at least six years, and up from 22% in 2016, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Still, shareholder proposals opposed by companies typically fail. Among more than 700 such proxy resolutions under consideration this season, less than three dozen have passed so far, figures compiled by Bloomberg show. If support appears high enough for a proposal to pass, companies typically ask activists to withdraw the proposal and negotiate, rather than face a defeat in the voting.
More than 25% of Bank of America Corp.’s shareholders supported a proposed racial-equity audit. A similar resolution filed with Wells Fargo & Co. garnered 13% of votes, the least among the companies so far. The lender has said it hired a third party to conduct a human-rights assessment, which includes a focus on racial equity, and will publish a summary of the results.”
The California Public Employees’ Retirement System and the California State Teachers’ Retirement System were among the Citigroup and Bank of America investors that voted in favor of the racial audit proposals.
All the companies recommended that investors vote against racial audits, saying they’ve already taken measures to address discrimination, such as investing in Black entrepreneurs, expanding credit and working to boost diversity within their ranks. Last year, Goldman Sachs became the only bank to say it wouldn’t underwrite public offerings for companies that lack a diverse board.
CtW said the only way to effectively address racial injustice and economic inequality is to study how the industry’s products and services contribute to imbalances. That would include analyzing things like mortgage lending, the number of bank branches in minority neighborhoods and corporate political contributions.
Citigroup last year published a report saying closing racial gaps would have generated an additional $16 trillion in U.S. economic output since 2000. The U.S. could gain $5 trillion more of economic activity over the next five years by ending the various gaps between Black and White Americans, analysts at the New York-based bank concluded.
Citigroup was among the companies that asked regulators to block the racial-audit resolution. Similar proposals are up for votes next month at Amazon.com Inc., JPMorgan Chase & Co. and State Street Corp
(Updates first chart, and adds details about Google in sixth paragraph and pension funds in the 10th.)
--With assistance from Sridhar Natarajan.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Saijel Kishan in New York at firstname.lastname@example.org;
Jeff Green in Southfield, Michigan at email@example.com
To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Tim Quinson at firstname.lastname@example.org
© 2021 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. Used with permission.