Welcome
Coronavirus Outbreak

Acting Navy Secretary Quits After Calling Carrier Captain Stupid

April 7, 2020, 10:26 PM

Acting Navy Secretary Thomas Modly resigned Tuesday after an uproar over his decision to remove -- and then ridicule -- the commander of a U.S. aircraft carrier who demanded that the Pentagon do more to stop a coronavirus outbreak spreading through his ship.

Modly relieved Captain Brett Crozier of his command for writing and distributing a memo pleading in urgent terms for all but a skeleton crew to be removed from the USS Roosevelt, which was sidelined in Guam. “We are not at war,” Crozier wrote. “Sailors do not need to die.”

Modly said the captain’s memo, which was made public by the San Francisco Chronicle, his hometown newspaper, “jeopardized the national security interests of the United States” and that the Navy was already addressing Crozier’s concerns.

While the Navy leader had the backing of his superiors initially, that support was undercut when an audio recording surfaced of Modly telling the carrier’s crew that Crozier was “too naive or too stupid” to lead the ship.

President Donald Trump, at a White House briefing on Tuesday, said he “had no role” in Modly’s departure but that the secretary “did that just to end that problem.”

On Monday, the president said he was going to look into the episode. While praising both Modly and Crozier, Trump signaled he didn’t think the Roosevelt’s departing commander deserved to have his career tarnished by the fracas.

“You have two good people and they are arguing,” Trump said.

On Tuesday, he said again that Crozier had made a mistake in writing the memo. “He didn’t have to be Ernest Hemingway,” the president said, adding that Modly “shouldn’t have said what he said.”

Defense Secretary Mark Esper, in a memo on Tuesday, said Modly’s decision to resign showed he was “putting the Navy and the sailors above self” and that “his care for the sailors was genuine.”

The carrier is setting pierside in Guam struggling with a growing number of infections. After Modly’s decision, Crozier won a spirited ovation from his crew when he departed his ship.

Democrats in Congress, including Speaker Nancy Pelosi and House Armed Services Chairman Adam Smith of Washington, had called for Modly to resign.

“Sadly, Acting Secretary Modly’s actions and words demonstrate his failure to prioritize the force protection of our troops,” Pelosi said in a statement Tuesday. “He showed a serious lack of the sound judgment and strong leadership needed during this time.”

Evacuating Crew

The Roosevelt has now evacuated at least 2,000 of some 4,800 sailors to the shore on Guam as it tests the crew for Covid-19 infection. The Navy hopes to decontaminate the ship while keeping a small crew onboard to run its nuclear reactors, mind its ammunition and look after other critical functions.

Modly said he had lost confidence in Crozier, who has tested positive for the virus, because the captain had carelessly shared the memo widely, causing unnecessary alarm among crew and military families, and should have known it would become public.

In a public apology hours later, Modly walked back his statement calling Crozier naive or stupid. “I believe, precisely because he is not naive and stupid, that he sent this alarming email with the intention of getting it into the public domain in an effort to draw public attention to the situation on this ship,” he said in the statement.

Changing Lineup

Modly has served as acting secretary since November. His predecessor as Navy secretary, Richard Spencer, was fired amid a Pentagon dust-up over Trump’s insistence that a Navy SEAL acquitted of murder should be allowed to keep a Trident decoration signifying his service.

Trump announced in February that he intended to nominate Kenneth Braithwaite as Navy secretary, a position that would require Senate confirmation. Braithwaite, a Navy veteran, is currently U.S. ambassador to Norway.

In the meantime, James McPherson, who was confirmed by the Senate last month as undersecretary of the Army, will be acting Navy secretary, according to people familiar with the personnel move. He’s a former Navy admiral, having served as its highest legal officer, judge advocate general, before retiring from the Navy service in 2006.

(Updates with Trump’s latest remarks, starting in fifth paragraph)

--With assistance from Jennifer Jacobs, Roxana Tiron and Justin Sink.

To contact the reporters on this story:
Tony Capaccio in Washington at acapaccio@bloomberg.net;
Travis Tritten in Arlington at ttritten@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Bill Faries at wfaries@bloomberg.net;
Paul Hendrie at phendrie2@bloomberg.net

Larry Liebert, John Harney

© 2020 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. Used with permission.

To read more articles log in. To learn more about a subscription click here.