Mastercard Loses $18.6 Billion Class Action Court Ruling (2)

Mastercard Inc. faces the prospect of a 14 billion-pound ($18.6 billion) U.K. class action -- the largest of its kind -- after losing another battle at the country’s highest court over illegal swipe fees.

The Supreme Court ruled in favor of a group behind a proposed British suit, representing some 46 million consumers. Friday’s decision also sets the stage for a slew of class-action cases, after the judges made it easier to bring mass claims.

Mastercard has faced numerous legal challenges since European Union courts said its payment fees unfairly restricted competition. The decision means the long-running British case, which started in 2016, will now be reconsidered by a specialist tribunal. Mastercard shares fell 1.2% in New York trading.

“Mastercard has been a sustained competition law breaker,” said Walter Merricks, the former head of the U.K. Financial Ombudsman Service, who is bringing the case. “Instead of apologizing and accepting responsibility for the wrongs it committed, all Mastercard has done is to bury its head in the sand and to get its lawyers to raise what have now been clearly and finally determined to be bad arguments.”

Mastercard said the legal case is “fundamentally flawed.”

“No U.K. consumers have asked for this claim,” the company said in a statement. “It is being driven by ‘hit and hope’ U.S. lawyers, backed by organizations primarily focused on making money for themselves.”

The decision was handed down following the death of Judge Brian Kerr, who had presided over the hearing. His vote would have led to a 3-2 ruling to dismiss the appeal. After his death, two dissenting judges dropped their opposition.

The case stems from an EU ruling that the card fees that the company had charged for transactions were unfair and a breach of competition law.

Card Swipes

It comes after the Supreme Court in June ruled against Mastercard and Visa Inc. in a similar case brought by some of the largest British retailers over the fees, levied by banks at rates set by the card companies each time a transaction leads to a card swipe at a register.

The ruling also paves the way for further consumer class-action lawsuits, which were made possible by a 2015 law change but have struggled to get traction. When considering the question of individual damages, the Supreme Court has now lowered the bar in similar group actions, said Louise Freeman, a competition lawyer at Covington & Burling.

The ruling means “it is not the job of the Competition Appeal Tribunal to set up too many hurdles,” she said.

(Updates with Mastercard shares in third paragraph.)

To contact the reporter on this story:
Jonathan Browning in London at jbrowning9@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Anthony Aarons at aaarons@bloomberg.net

Christopher Elser

© 2020 Bloomberg L.P. All rights reserved. Used with permission.